!
The Collie Nose
!"#$%&'()'*++$&',)'-./"0&1'23(2'
'
!
!"#$%&'('#)*&# $*$+#&,'+#(*&%-*,.-*
/'0-1/++$*+0*2+//'-*3-(4"-*+0*
5%-& ,-%*
6//'#+'(7*8',.+",*9+"% *)-#-%+"(*
4+#,%'1",'+#(:*; -*4+"/$*#+,*
<%+='$-
*
,.-*/-=-/*+0*4&%-*,.&,*&//*+"%*4+//'-*
4+><&#'+#(*#--$*&#$*$-(-%=-7**
2356*;'//*#-=-%*,"%#*$+;#*&*4+//'-*
0+%*&#9*>-$'4&/*%-&(+#7*6#*0&4,:*
;.-#*;-*$+*.-& %*+0*,.-(-*(<-4'&/*
#--$*4&(-(:*;-*?#+; *,.&,*,.-%-*'(*
#+*1-,,-%*</&4-*,.&#*23567*@0,-#*
,.-(-*4&(-(*&%-*0'#&#4'&//9*-A<-#B
VLYH7KDW¶VZKHQWKHFDOOJRHVRXW
,+*9+":*+"%*("<<+%,*1&(-7*C#$*9+"*
.&=-*#-=-%*/-,*"(*$+;#7**
3-4-#,/9*;-*,++?*'#*,;+*1-&",'0"/*
1+9(:*39&#*&#$*D-##-$97*E.-( -*
,;+*1+9(*;-%-*("00-%'#)*0%+>*$-B
>+$-4,'4*>&#)-:*&* (-=-%-*(?'#*
4+#$','+#*F4&"(-$*19*>',-(G*,.&,*'(*
-A,%->-/9*$'00'4"/,*,+*,%-&,7**
E+*0"%,.-%*4+></'4&,-*>&,,-%(:*&*
$&'/9*$+(-*+0*6#,-%4-<,+%*;&(*%-B
H"'%-$*0+%*&*>'#'>">*+0*IJ*$&9(7*
C(*9+"*&//*?#+;:*6#,-%4-<,+%*'(**
-A,%->-/9*$'00'4"/,*,+*+1,&'#*$" -*,+*
&*.&/,*'#*<%+$"4,'+#7*K=-#*(+:*
;.-#*,.-*4&//*0+%*.-/<*;&(*<+(,-$:*
9+":*+"%*
("<<+%,:*
>&#&)-$*,+*$+B
#&,-*-#+").*6#,-%4-<,+%*0+%*1+,.*
1+9(:*&(*;-//*&(*0'#&#4'&/*4+#,%'1"B
,'+#(*,+*4+=-%*&//*,%-&,>-#,7*
8.-#-=-%*&*4&//*0+%*.-/<*'(*<+(,-$ :*
-=-%9*$+#&,'+#*'(*"(-$*,+*1-#-0',*
+"%*4+//'-(7*L'></9*&(?* 39&#:***
D-##-$9:*M%+$9*&#$*E%-=-%:*,+*
#&>-*N"(,*&*0-;O*
M+&%$*P%-('$-#,*Q+.#*29>-%>&#*
45'67##'89:+1"/&'
!
"#$%&!'(&!)(*!+,$!*(-$.!/012$!32!
+,$!)11'*4!+3$'!+1!(!+%$$!12!(!*,1%+!
0$(*,.!5,$!61003$!*,37+$'!32!+,$!'3%+4!
+%&328!+1!8$+!61-71%+(90$.!:$!'3'2;+!
<2'$%*+(2'!),(+!,$!,('!'12$!+1!
01*$!,3*!,1-$.!:$!-3**$'!+,$!
,(2'*!+,(+!126$!*+%1=$'!,3*!,$('!
(2'!+,$!#136$!+,(+ !+10'!,3-!+,(+!,$!
)(*!(!811'!91&.!
>$*3'$*!9$328!012$0&4!,$!)(*!32 !?(32.!:3*!+,36=!7<00!
61(+!)(*!(!-(++$'!-$**4!(2'!,$!+%3$'!+1!*6%(+6,!
(2'!93+$!(+!+,$!,3''$2!-12*+$%*!6,$)328!12!,3*!
*=32.!:$!+%3$'!+1!- 1#$4!9<+!+,$!-(+*!)$%$!+)3*+328!
32+1!+,$!*17+!*=32!17!,3*!+<--&!(2'!<2'$%!,3*!
0$8*.!@1!,$!)(3 +$'!(2'!,1?$'!+,(+!3+!)1<0'2;+!*+(%+!
%(32328!(8(32!±!+,(+!+1'(&!)1<0' !9$!(!'(&!+,(+!,$!
)1<0'!$(+.!
:$(%328!711+*+$?*!32!+,$!0$(#$*4!,$ !%1*$!)3+,!,3*!$(%*!<?4!+(30!)(88328!
(2'!(2A31<*!$&$*!?$$%328!+,%1<8,!+,$!+%$$*.!:$!%$61823 B$'!,<-(2!711+C
*+$?*4!9<+!,$!'3'2;+!=21)!+,$!)1-(2!),1!*+1??$'!32!+,$!60$(%328!+1!
*+(%$!(+!,3-.!
@,$!61#$%$'!,$%!-1<+,4!),3*?$%3284!³2KQRQRQR:LWKKHUKDQG
1<+*+%$+6,$'!(2'!01#$!32!,$%!,$(%+!701)328!*+%(38,+!32+1!,3*4!*,$!(?C
?%1(6,$'!(2'!8(#$!+,$!61003$!,1?$.!:$!-1#$'!+1)(%'!,$%4!?<*,328!,3*!
,$('!<?!<2'$%!,$%!*17+!,(2'4!*(#1%328!,$%!+1<6,.!@,$!9$6(-$!,3*!/28$0.!
/*!(!-(2!(??%1(6,$'4!+,$!61003$!<2'$%*+11'!+,(+!/28$0!)(*!(28%&4!9<+!
21+!)3+,!,3-.!
D5,3*!3*!21!)(&!71%!(!61003$!+1!03#$4D!*,$!*(3'.!DE!)12;+!*+(2'!71%!+,3*. !F1<!
'1!*1-$+,328!%38,+!21)GD!
5,$!-(2!),1!*1-$+3-$*!9%1<8,+!'18!711'!*,%<88$'!(2'!+10'!/28$04!
DF1<!)(2+!,3-H!5(=$!,3-.D!
/*!+,$!-(2!)(0=$'!()(&4!/28$0!<2+3$'!+,$!0$(*,!(2'!7%$$'!+,$!61003$!
7%1-!+,$!+%$$.!:3*!7$$+ !'(26$'!(*!,$!)(0=$'!9$*3'$!/28$0!(2'!,3*!$&$*!
)(+6,$'!,$%!7(6$.!:$!=2$)!+,(+!/28$0!)(*!-(=328!3+!(00!%38,+!(8(32.!@,$!
1?$2$'!+,$!9(6=!' 11 %!+1!,$%!6(%!(2'!<%8$'!,3-!+1!8$+!32.!
419;&<&91/='>'?";&'@/"15'
@&&'4A>!B8B>AC)'D9E&'2'
A59:'9:F'G&::&F5'''
":'A"9F'/"'A&.";&15'
'
*:/&1.&D/"1'HDF9/&'
/*!,$!(*!*$++0$'!32+1!+,$!0$(+,$%!*$(+4!*,$!(*=$'4!DI,(+!3*!,3*!2(-$HD!!
5,$!-(24!+<%2328!,3*!9(6=!12!+,$! 61003$!71%!+,$!0(*+!+3-$4!%$?03$'4!
%UDYHKHDUW´!
5,3*!)1-(2!±!6(%328!$21<8,!+1!)(0=!+,%1<8,!+,$!)11'*!(2'!*+(2'!<?!
(8(32*+!),(+!)(*2;+!%38,+!±!9%1<8,+!>%(#$,$(%+!+1!J1003$!K$*6<$!17!
L%$(+$%!E003213*.!>%(#$,$(%+!)(*!7%3 8,+$2$'!),30$!9$328!+%(2*?1%+$'4!
9<+!%$61823B$'!+,$!01#$!+,(+!*+(%+$'!)3+,!/28$0.!
:$!61<0'!*$$!01#$!*,32$!+,%1<8,!+,$!$&$*!17!$#$%&12$!),1!+1<6,$'!,3-.!
:$!)(*!*+%1=$'!(+!+,$!#$+;*!17736$!(2'!)(*!83#$2!711'!(2'!(!90(2=$+!+1!
*0$$?!12.!5,$!8%11-$%;* !*=3007<0!,(2'*!6(%$7<00&!*,(#$'!+,$!-(+*!7%1-!
WKHFROOLH¶VWRUPHQWHGVNLQDVWKHGRJVWRRGTXLHWO\IRUKRXUV! M1*328!+,$!
+(280$'4!-(++$'!61(+!)(*!03=$!*,$''328!+,$!?(*+.!
5,$24!(+!,3*!0 1#328!71*+$%!,1-$4!,$!71<2 '!*17+!9$'*!(2'!8 11'!711'!!
(8(32.!/2'!,$!,('!1+,$%!61003 $*!+1!?0 (&!)3+,!(2'!(00!+,$!)(+$%!,$!)(2+C
$'.!>$*+!17!(004!,$!,('!01#$!7%1-!?$1?0$!),1!8(#$!3+!)3 +,1<+!%$*$%#(+3124!
HYHQWKRXJKWKH\¶GKDYHWRRQHGD\VD\JRRGE\H!
5,(+!'(&!6(-$!(2'!>%(#$,$(%+!-$+!(!)1-(2 !),1!,('!*<77$%$'!8%$(+!
01**!±!),1!,('!$2'<%$'!?,&*3 6(0!,(%'*,3?!(2'!),1*$!,$(%+!)(*!-3**328!
(21+,$%!61003$.!!>%(#$,$(%+!'$*6%39$*!+,(+!'(&N!
!R':*-=-%9+#-O*6,S(*>-:*M%&=-.-&%,:*&#$*6*4&#S,*;&',*,+*,-//* 9+"*,.&,*6*>-,*
>9*0+%-=-%*>+>*,+#').,*&#$*6S>*&,*>9*=-%9*+;#*0+%-=-%*.+>-O*
8.-#*>9*0+(,-%*>+> *+<-#-$*,.-*1&4?*+0*.-%*=&#*&0,-%*+"%*/+#)*$%'=-*
,+#').,*&#$*6*(&;*T'((*U&"%&*(',,'#)*+#*.-%*0%+#,*(,-<(:*6*;-#, *%').,*"<*
,+*.-%*;',.*4+//'-*?' ((-(*&#$*,%'-$*,+*4/'>1*'#,+*.-%*/&<O*R-%*&%>(*4"%=-$*
&%+"#$*>-*&#$*6*0-/,*.-%*,%->1/-*&(*(.-*1-#,*.-%*.-&$*'#,+*>9*#-4?7*6*
)+,*&*0"##9*0--/'#)*'#*>9*.-&%,7*C#$*%').,*,.-#*6*?#-;*,.&,*T'((*
U&"%&*#--$-$*>-*&( *>"4.*&(*6*#--$-$*.-%7!
!6*(,&9-$*4/+(-*,+*T'((*U&"%&*&(*(.-*&#$*>9*0+(,-%*>+>*,&/?-$7*6*?-<,*
<",,'#)*>9*<&;*+#*T'((*U&"%&S(*/-)*(+*,.&,*>9*0+(,- %*>+>*;+"/$*?#+;*
,.&,*6*;&#,-$*T'((*U&"%&*,+*1-*>9*0+%-=-%*>+>:*&0%&'$*,.&,*(.-*>').,*
#+,*?#+;*,.&,*;-*1-/+#)-$*,+)-,.-%O*
!'#&//9:*0'#&//9:*>9*0+(,-%*>+>*(,++$*"<*&#$*<",*(+>-*<&<-%(*'#,+ *.-%*
<"%(-*&#$*(>'/-$*$+;#*&,*>-7*L.-*/-&#-$*+=-%:*,++?*>9*0&4-*'#*.-%*
.&#$(:*?'((-$*>-*+#*>9*0+%-.-&$*&#$*(&'$*(+0,/9:*7KLVLVIURP6XVLH´
L.-*?'((-$*>9*#+ (-*&#$*(&'$:*VC#$*,.'(*'(*0%+>*L.-%9/--7V*C#$*,.-#*(.-*
?'((-$*>-*&)&'#*&#$*(&'$:*VC#$*,.' (*+#-*'(*0%+>*>-*&#$*-=-%9+#-*-/(-*&,*
&ROOLH5HVFXHZKRKDVORYHG\RXDQGLVJODG\RXDUHKRPH´!
M(<%(4!>%(#$,$(%+;*!2$ )!-1-4!%$?1%+$'!+,(+!),30$!>%(#$,$(%+!3*!?0(&7<04!
,$!=21)*!+1!9$!#$%&!%$*?$6+7<0 !17!,$%!*326$!*,$!<*$*!(!)(0=$%.!:$!*+(2'*!
(2'!)(3+ *!(+!+,$!+1?!17!+,$!*+$?*!<2+30!M(<%(!%$(6,$*!+,$!91++1-!)3+,!,$%!
)(0=$%!(2'!6(00*!,3-.!:$!)(0=*!O<3$+0&!(2'!?(+3$2+0&!9$*3'$!,$%4!
-(+6,328
!
KLVVWHSVWRKHUVDVVKHPRYHVWKURXJKWKHKRXVH/DXUDFDOOVLW³VWHS
VWRSVWHSVWRS´%UDYHKHDUWZKRZDVDEDQGRQHGRQWKHHQGRIDURSH
O<36=0&!9$6(-$!(!01#3284!%$*?$6+7<0!?(%+2$%!71%!M(<%(!±!), 36,!*?$(=*!
#10<-$*!(91<+!,3*!2190$!*1<0.!
I,$2!+10'!17!+,$!1<+?1<%328!17!01#$!7%1-!J1003$!K$*6<$!(*!$#$%&12$!
,$(%'!+,(+!>%(#$,$(%+!,('!71<2'!,3*!,1-$4!M(<%(!%$0(&$'!+,(+!>%(#$C
,$(%+!)(*!21+!+,$! 120&!037$!+,(+!)(*!*(#$'!)3+,!+,3*!('1?+312!±!+,(+!
J1003$!
K$*6<$!8(#$!*<2*,32$!+1!,$%!037$!(8(32.!!
4A>!B8B>AC)'I1"%'D9E&'( ''
/!*,1%+(8$!17!E2+$%6$?+1%!3*!6(<*C
328!?%190$-*!71%!61003$!1)2$%*!(2'!
%$*6<$!8%1<?*.!
5,$!JKLE!)$9*3+$!%$6$2+0 &!(*=$'!
71%!'12(+312*!+1!+%$(+!K&(2!(2'!
P$22$'&4!+)1!6100 3$*!*<77$%328!
7%1-!-(28$.!5,$&!2$$'$'!'(30&!
'1*$*!17!E2+$%6$?+1% .!Q$*?3+ $!(!
*<??0&!*,1%+(8$4!-(2 &!%$('$%*!
'12(+$'!E2+$%6$?+1%!(2'!(!6%3*3*!
)(*!(#$%+$'.!
/661%'328!+1!+,$!R 1#(%+3*!)$9C
*3+$4!))).(,.21#(%+3*.<*ST/US
T/U.,+-4!?%$?%1'<6+312!+$*+328!
17!@$2+32$0!3*!<2'$%!)(&.!E2!+,$!
/<8.!VW!<?'(+$4!R1#(%+3*!'3'!21+!
?%1#3'$!(!?%1'<6+312!*6,$'<0$.!!
R1#(%+3*!(0*1!'3'!21+!?%1#3'$!32C
71%-(+312!12!+,$!*+(+<*!17!E2+$%C
6$?+1%.!:1)$#$%4!3+!3*!,1?$'!+,(+!
@$2+32$0!X),36,!<*$*!-309$-&632!
1A3-$!%(+,$%!+,(2!3#$%-$6+32Y!
)300!9$!?%1'<6$'!*112.!Z0$(*$!
6,$6=!)3+,!&1<%!#$+$%32(%3(2.!
/21+,$%!6126$%2!3*!(!*,1%+(8$!17!
+,$!'%<8*!+,(+!(%$!<*$'!+1!+%$(+!
,$(%+)1%-.!/661%'328!+1!(2!(%+360$!
32!+,$!/+0(2+(![1<%2(04!(0+$%2(+3#$!
+%$(+-$2+*!(%$!(#(30(90$4!9<+!+,$&!
,(#$!+1!9$!<*$'!0128$%.!/*!(!%$C
*<0+4!(2!327$*+$'!'18!3*!0(3'!<?!71%!
(!-<6,!0128$%!+3-$.!\1%$!32 71%C
-(+312!)300!71001)!32!+,$!2$A+!
3**<$.!!
2'
]10<2+$$%*!(%$!2$$'$'!71%!+)1!+1!
+,%$$!,1<%*!(+!+,$!J,36(81!Z$+!
@,1)4!+1!9$!,$0'!^_!(.-.C`!? .-.!
@(+<%'(&!(2'!@<2'(&4!R1#.!
^_C^^4!
(+!P(2$!J1<2+&!T(3%8%1<2'*.!
!
51!*382!<? 4!?0$(*$!6(00!\36,$00$!
:3%*6,!(+!Xab_Y!`cVCaddc!1%!$-(30!
-,3%*6,d^`be(++.2$+.!]10<2+$$%*!
'1!21+!?(&!('-3**312.!
!!
/!f^C177!('-3**312!61<?12!)300!9$!
(#(30(90$!*112!(+!61003$%$*6<$.1%8!
(2'!,(0 7!17!+,$!fa!? %36$!)300!81!+1!
JKLE.!"2g1&!*$-32(%*!(2'!*$$!+,$!
0(+$*+!?$+!?%1'<6+*!(2'!*$%#36$*.!
J<7.9E"'K&/'@<"L'
!
,'
45'M97#'N7&F17.<+&:'
>$328!(!'$'36(+$'!(23-(0!%$*6<$!#10<2+$$%!%$O<3%$*!*+%$28+,4!+3%$0$**!$2$%8&!(2'!91<2'0$**!61-?(**312.!M<6=30&!
71%!J1003$!K$*6<$!17!L%$(+$%!E003213*4!]36=3!I30'$%!$A$-?0373$*!$(6,!17!+,$*$!(++%39<+$*!(*!+,$!#36$!?%$*3'$2+!(2'!
32+(=$!611%'32(+1%.!
@,$!(**$**$*!-$'36(0!2$$'*!(2'!*-11+,0&!1%6,$*+%(+$*!+,$!-(2&!%$O<3%$'!-1#$*!3+!+(=$*!+1!8$+!(!*+%$**$'C
1<+4!6127<*$'!61003$!7%1-!?132+!/!+1!?132+!>!(*!O<36=0&!(2'!*(7$0&!(*!?1**390$.!
51!732'!*10<+312*!71%!,1-$0$**!61003$*4!]36=3!,( *!9$61-$!(2!326%$'390$!2$+)1%=$%.!@,$!)1%=*!60 1*$0&!)3+,!7$001)!
FROOLHUHVFXHJURXSVZLWKRQHJRDOLQPLQG³:HDUHRQHELJKDSS\IDPLO\DQGZHZRUNWRJHWKHUWRKHOSRQH
DQRWKHURXW´!
9LFNLODXJKVDVVKHUHPHPEHUVKRZVKHILUVWEHFDPHLQYROYHGZLWK&5*,³,ZRUPHGP\ZD\LQ,DJUHHGWR
WDNHLQDKRPHOHVVFROOLHFRQWDFWHG&ROOLH5HVFXHDQGVDLGµ,UHVFXHGDFROOLH,¶OOIRVWHUWKHGRJ0D\,SOHDVH
EHDSDUWRI\RXURUJDQL]DWLRQQRZ"¶6LQFHWKHQ,KDYHIRVWHUHGKXQGUHGVRIGRJVWKDWKDYHWRXFKHGP\KHDUW
LQPRUHZD\VWKDQ\RXFDQLPDJLQH´!
9LFNL¶VKXVEDQG'DYHEXLOWDZHOOC?0(22$'!
=$22$0!),30$!*,$!(??03$'!+1!9$61-$!(!*+(+$C
OLFHQVHGDQLPDOVKHOWHU7KHROGDGDJH³EXLOGLW
DQGWKH\ZLOOFRPH´ZRUNHG6RRQWKHNHQQHO
)(*!7<00.!
³7DNLQJWKHVHWDWWHUHGDQGKRUULEO\QHJOHFWHG
*1<0*!(2'!732'328!+,$!'18!32*3'$!±!+,3*!3*!
,$(#$2
!
IRUPH´VKHVD\V!
9LFNLVKDPHOHVVO\UHIHUVWRKHUVHOIDVD³IRVWHU
IOXQN\´7KH\KDYHDGRSWHGIRXURIWKHFROOLHV
+,(+!*,$!,(*!71*+$%$'!X?36+<%$'!32!?,1+1Y.!
³'DYHLVDWURRSHU´VKHVD\V³+HLVXQGHU
*+(2'328!(2'!,$0?7<0!(2'!,(*!?<+!<?!)3+,!
PDQ\ORQJVOHHSOHVVQLJKWVRIGRJJLHGUDPD´!
,WORRNVDVLIKHGRHVQ¶WJHWWRVLWRQKLVFRXFKPXFKHLWKHU!
9LFNLKDVPDQ\VWRULHVEXW&DVH\¶VLVVSHFLDO³+HZDVWKHRQHWKDWZDVVRGLIILFXOWWRJLYHXS+HFDPHLQDV
J(**(2'%(.!><+!E!*112!%$(03B $'!*,$!)( *!(!,$4!*1!E!2(-$'!,3-!J(*$&.!: $!)(*!(!-$**!±!-(++$'!+1!+,$!*=324!
IOHDVWLFNVWHUULEOHGLDUUKHDKHDUWZRUPDQGDEDGFDVHRIFDQLQHLQIOXHQ]D´!
:$!2$$'$'!+1!9$!O<(%(2+32$'!3 2!+,$3%!-30=!,1<*$!(2'!)(*!610'!(7+$%!9$328!*,(#$'.!
9LFNLODXJKVDVVKHUHPHPEHUVWKHWLPHWKDW'DYHORRNHGDW&DVH\DQGWKHQDWKHUDQGDVNHG³,VWKDWGRJ
ZHDULQJP\ORQJXQGHUZHDU"´!
6KHDQVZHUHG³<HVEXWKHLVZDUP´! !
]36=3!*?$2+!,1<%*!)1%=328!)3+ ,!J(*$&.!@,$!8(#$!,3-!8 <3'(26$!(2'!+(<8, +!,3-!+1!9$!(!,1<*$!'18!)3+,!-(22$%*.!
³:KHQ,ILQGDQXWEDOOZKRWXUQVRXWWREHDJUHDWGRJDIWHUVRPHZRUNWKDW¶VZKHUH,ILQGWKHPRVWHQMR\
PHQW´9LFNLVD\V!
J(*$&!71<2'!(!811'!,1-$!)3+,!\36,$00$!K18$%*4!9<+!*+300!%$-$-9$%*!]36=3.!/2'!\36,$00$!9$6(-$!(!JKLE!#10<2C
+$$%!(7+$%!-$$+328!]36=3.!
9LFNL:LOGHU$'RJ¶V%HVW)ULHQG'
@&&'O*?NBA)'D9E&'P'
!
P'
/21+,$%!*?$63(0!'18!)(*!@('3 $.!
³6DGLHKDGEHHQVWDUYHGDQGKDGKHDUWZRUPV´9LFNLVD\V³6RPHGRJVVDLO
WKURXJKKHDUWZRUPWUHDWPHQW%XWIRU6DGLHLWZDVEUXWDO´!
]36=3!%$6(00*!12$!-1%2328!),$2!*,$!71<2'!@('3 $!)$(=!)3+,!*$#$%$!9011' &!'3(%%,$(!
(2'!#1-3+328.!
³,FDUULHGKHUWRWKHFDUORDGHGKHUXSDQGGURYHLPPHGLDWHO\WRWKHYHWHULQDU\
FOLQLFZKHUHVKHZDVVWDELOL]HG´VKHVD\V!
9LFNLODXJKVDQGFRQWLQXHV³5HOLHYHGNQRZLQJ6DGLHZDVRXWRIGDQJHU,ORRNHG
GRZQRQO\WRUHDOL]H,KDGIRUJRWWHQWRJHWGUHVVHGDQG,ZDVVWLOOLQP\SDMDPDV´!
@('3$!71<2'!(!8%$(+!,1-$!(2'!,$%!('1?+$%!9$6(-$!(!#10<2+$$%!)3+,!5%3C@+(+$!
J1003$
!
K$*6<$.!/8(324!3+!g<*+!81$*!+1!*,1)!,1)!612+(831<*!]36=3!3*G!!!!!
I,30$!,$%!)1%=!3*!%$)(%'3284!*,$!7(6$*!+1<8,!-1-$2+*!+11.!@1-$+3-$*!*,$!,(*!+1!
=$$?!(!O<3$+!+128<$!),$2!'$(0328!7(6$!+1!7(6$!)3 +,!?$1?0$!),1!(%$!83#328!<?!(!
'18.
!
³:KHQ,VHHDQHJOHFWHGGRJ,WHOOP\VHOIµ9LFNLMXVWJHWWKHGRJLQWKHFDUNHHS
TXLHWDQGJHWDZD\IDVW¶´!
/*!32+(=$!611%'32(+1%4!3+!3 *!$#$2!+1<8,$%!+1!+<%2!()(&!'18*!9$6(<*$!+,$&!(%$!21+!
61003$*.!]36=3!+%3$*!+1!,$0?!(2'!83#$*!*<88$*+312*4!9<+ !3+!3*!'$?%$**328!(2'!)$38,*!
,$(#30&!12!,$%!=32'!,$(%+.!! !
³9LFNL¶VNQRZOHGJHRIFROOLHVLVXQPDWFKHG:KHWKHURQHQHHGVKHOSZLWKKHDOWK
LVVXHVGLHWJURRPLQJRUEHKDYLRUSUREOHPVVKHKDVWKHDQVZHU´VD\VIRVWHU
KRPH&KDLUSHUVRQ6XVLH0RQFHNZKRYLHZV9LFNLDVKHUPHQWRU³6KHIRVWHUVWKH
WRXJKHVWFDVHVKHUVHOI%DVLFDOO\9LFNLGRHVDQ\WKLQJDQGHYHU\WKLQJ´!
]36=3!)$(%*!-(2&!,(+*!)3+,!'$'36(+312!(2'!61-?(**312.!@,$!,(*!+3-$!(2'!(8(32!
812$!(91#$!(2'!9 $&12'!+1!*(#$!+,$!-1*+!?(+,$+36!(2'!2$$'&.!:$%!%$)(%'!±!(!!
8$2+0$!036=!17!+,$!,(2'!(2'!(!g1&7<0!)(8!17!(!+,(2=7<0!+(30.!!!!
!7.Q7'O7#F&1'."%D&/&+'7:'
19##5'9:F'"0&F7&:.&'/179#+'
L7/<'<&1'F"E+R'@<&'7+'D7.S
/$1&F'L7/<'@<9:&'
T90";&U'
9:F'4#9V&'T0&#"LUR'
O*?NBA)'I1"%'D9E&',''
>'K7.:7.'/"'A&%&%0&1''
!
W'
!
?&91:7:E'/<&'A"D&+'"I'>E7#7/5'
45'J"##&&:'?&": 91F'
!
/*!E!9$8(2!(8303+&!60(**!)3+ ,!-&!61003$!+,3*!*<--$%4!E!+,1<8,+!-&!
'%$(-*!)$%$!1#$%!+,$!73%*+!'(&.!\&!VC&$(%C10'!90<$!-$%0$!61003$!+11=!
12$!011=!(+!+,$!'18!)(0=4!(!9(0(26$!9$(-!71%!'18*4!(2'!%(2!+,$!
1+,$%
!
)(&.!
!
/7+$%!g<*+!(!7$)!)$ $=*4!,$!21)!603-9*!+,$!/C7%(-$4!9(0(26$*!12!+,$!
'18!)(0=!(2'!01#$*!+,$!+<22 $0*.!><+!+,$!9$*+!3-?%1#$-$2+!3*!,3*!
*$07C
61273'$26$.!!!
!
/8303+&!3*!'$*6%39$'!(*!(!'18!*?1%+!32!),36,!(!,(2'0$%!'3%$6+*!(!'18!
+,%1<8,!(2!19*+(60$!61<%*$!32!(!%(6$!71%!91+,!+3-$!(2'!(66<%(6&.!
!
@326$!)$!*+300!,(#$!(!0128!)(&!+1!814!E!%$6$2+0 &!+<%2$'!+1!JKLE!-$-C
9$%*!>19!(2'!Q$$!h0*12!71%!('#36$.!Q$$!,(*!61-?$+$'!71%!^c!&$(%*!
(2'!>19!,(*!^b!& $(% *!17!$A?$%3$26$!32!(8303+&.!/00!*3A!17!+,$3%!61003$*!
X71<%!)$%$!%$*6<$*Y!,(#$!?(%+363?(+$'!32!(8303+&!61-?$+3+312*.!5,$3%!'18!J1'&4!(!JKLE!%$*6<$4!)(*!12$!17!+,$!
-1*+!,38,0 &!+3+0$'!(8303+&!61003$*!$#$%.!T1%!32*+(26$4!,$!)(*!+,$!73%*+!61003$!+1!9$61-$!+,$!/-$%36(2!P$22$0!J0<9!
\(*+$%!/8303+&!J,(-?312!(2'!3*!+,$!120&!61003$!+1!$(%2!+,$!M37$+3-$!/6,3$#$-$2+!/)(%'!7%1-!+,$!i23+$'!@+(+$*!
Q18!/8303+&!/**163(+312.!!
!
5,$!h0*12*!(2*)$ %$'!+,$!71001)328!O<$*+312*!+1!*,(%$!+,$3%!$A?$%+3*$!12!,1)!+1!9$!*<66$**7<0!32!(8303+&.!
J9:'9:5'F"E'F"'L&##'7:'9E7#7/5'/197 :7:EX'
\1*+!'18*!+,(+!(%$!32!811'!?,&*36(0!612'3+312!6(2!'1!)$00!32!(8303+&.!5,$%$!(%$!*1-$!9%$$'*!+,(+!(%$!g<*+!21+!
*<3+$'!71%!3+!'<$!+1!+,$3%!*+%<6+<%$!1%!*3B$. !
'
O<9/'91&'/<&'0&:&I7/+X'
/*3'$!7%1-!+,$!19#31<*!?,&*36(0!,$(0+,!9$2$73+ *4!?%1#3'$'!+,$!+%(32$%!('1?+ *!(!?1*3+3#$!(++3+<'$!+1)(%'!+,$!
*?1%+4!3+!3*!)12'$%7<0!71%!9<30'328!(!601*$!%$0(+312*,3?!9$+)$$2!'18!(2'!,(2'0$%.!!!
!
O<9/'L7##'/<&'F"E'#&91:X'
E23+3(00&4!+,$!'18!,(*!+1!0 $(%2!+1!716<*!12!,3*!,(2'0$%4!3260<'328!9(*36!19$'3$26$!61--(2'*.!T1%!$A(-?0$4!+,$!
'18!2$$'*!+1!9$!(90$!+1!)1%=!%$0 3(90&!177C0$(*,!32!(2!$2#3%12-$2+!),$%$!1+,$%!'18*!(%$!(0*1!)1%=328!177C0$(*,!
(+!+,$!*(-$!+3-$.!5,$!'18*!(0*1!2$$'!+1!'$#$01?!611%'32(+3124!91'&!()(%$2$**!(2'!g<-?328!*=300*.!5,$*$!'1!
21+!2$6$**(%30&!61-$!2(+<%(00&!+1!(00!'18*!(2'!2$$' !+1!9$!+(<8,+!32!(!+,1<8,+7<0!(2'!?1*3+3#$!-(22$%.!!
!
5,$!'18*!(0*1!2$$' !+1!0$(%2!+1!9$61-$!?%17363$2+!(+!+,$!(8303+&!$O<3?-$2+!±!+3%$4!)$( #$!?10$*4!+$$+$%C+1++$%4!/C
7%(-$4!'18!)(0=!(2'!?(<*$!+(90$.!E+!3*!3-?1%+(2+!71%!+,$!'18*!+1!0$(%2!+1!?$%71%-!+,$*$!19*+(60$*!*(7$0&!(2'!
$77363$2+0&.!5,$&!(%$! 73%*+!+(<8,+!91'&!()(%$2$**!32!(!2<-9$%!17!)(&*4!*<6,!(*!)(0=328!12!91(%'*!12!+,$!
8%1<2'!(2'!)(0 =328!+,%1<8,!0(''$%*!(2'!1#$%!'377$%$2+!*<%7( 6$*.!/*!+,$!'18*!9$61-$!61-71%+(90$!)3+,!+,$!!!
19*+(60$*4!,$38,+!(2'!'37736<0+&!(%$!8%('<(00&!%(3*$'!+1!+,$!0 $#$0 *!+,(+!+,$!'18*!)300!*$$!32!61-?$+3+312.!
'
8"L'#":E'F"&+'/197:7:E'/5D7.9##5'/9Q&'0&I"1&'."%D&/7/7":+'.9:' 0&'F":&X'
E+!'$?$2'*!12!+,$!(8$!+,(+!+,$!'18!*+(%+*!+%(323284!+,$!2(+<%(0 !(?+3+<'$!+,$!'18!9%328*!+1!+,$!+%(32328!(2'!+,$!
81(0*!17!+,$!,(2'0$%.!5,$!-1%$!+3-$!32#$*+$'!32!9<30'328!(!*+%128!+%(32328!71<2'(+3 124!+,$!-1%$!03=$0&!+,$!'18!
ZLOOEHVXFFHVVIXO'HH¶VILUVWDJLOLW\GRJ&RG\EHJDQFRPSHWLQJDIWHUIRXUPRQWKVRIWUDLQLQJ.QRZLQJZKDW
*,$!=21)*!21)4!+,(+!)(*!%$(00&!+11!*112.!><+!,$!,('!(! #$%&!*<66$**7<0!(8303+&!6(%$$%!(2&)(&. !:$%!2$)!?<??&!
,(*!9$$2!32!60(**$*!71%!2$(%0&!(!&$(%.!/2'!3+!)300!9$!(+!0$(*+!(21+,$%!*3A!-12+,*!9$71%$!*,$!*$$*!+,$!*,1)!%328!
(2'!(21+,$%!&$(%!9$7 1% $!*,$!*,1)*!%$8<0(%0&.!Z(%+!17!+,$!%$(*12!71%!)(3+328!+,3*!0128!3*!+1!(001)!+,$!'18!+1!!!
-(+<%$4!91+,!?,&*3 6(00&!(2'!-$2+(00&.!!
!
@&&'>M*?*CY)'D9E&'Z'
[7":9)'L<"'0&#":E+'/"'4"0'9:F 'N&&'
-#+":)'7+'+<"L:'."%D&/7:E'7:'9E7#7/5'
9/'/<&'J"##7&'J#$0'"I'>%&17.9'\9/7":9#'
@D&.79#/5R'K<"/"'05']917#5:'J#95/":'
!
Z'
!
8"L'%$.<'D19./7.&'7+':&&F&F'0&/L&&:'."%D&/7/7":+X''
M16(00&4!-1*+!(8303+&!61-?$+3+1%*!81!+1!(8303+&!60(** $*!(+!0$(*+!126$!(!)$$=.!I$!?$%*12(00&!+(=$!1<%!'18*!+,(+!
(%$!(6+3#$0&!+%(32328!1%!61-?$+328!+1!+)1!60(**$*!?$%!)$$=.!E+!3 *!(0*1!3-?1%+(2+!+,(+!+,$!'18*!8$+!%$8<0(%!?,&*3C
6(0!$A$%63*$!+1!*+(&!32!811'!612'3 +312!±!(8303+&!3*!7(3%0&!,(%'!?,&*36(0!)1%=!71%!+,$!'18*.!E2!(''3+3124!-(2&!(8303+&!
$2+,<*3(*+*!1)2!12$!1%!-1%$!?3$6$*!17!(8303+&!$O<3?-$2+!+,(+!+,$&!<*$!+1!+%(32!(+!,1-$.!I$(#$!?10$*!(2'!
g<-?*!(%$!?%19(90&!-1*+!61--120&!*$$2.!
'
O<9/'91&'/<&'D&1+":9#'1&L91F+ 'I"1'5"$X'
/8303+&!,(*!#(*+0&!3-?%1#$'!+,$!912'!9$+)$$2!<*!(2'!1<%!'18*.!E+!,( *!(0*1!3-? %1#$'!1<%!61273'$26$!32!1<%!
'18*.!/2'!3+!,(*!,$0?$'!+%(2*71%-!+,$-!32+1!,38,0&!7<26+312(0!(2' !*163(0!7(-30&!-$-9$%*.!T1<%!17!+,$!*3A!'18*!
ZH¶YHKDGZHUHUHVFXHVDQGKDGYDULRXVEHKDYLRULVVXHVWKDWWKHDJLOLW\WUDLQLQJDQGFRPSHWLWLRQKHOSHGWR
1#$%61-$.!I$!$2g1&!(8303+ &!9$6(<*$!3+!3*!(2!$A,30(%(+328!+$(-!*?1%+.!E+!3 *!(!+, %300!+1!+(=$!12!(!'37736<0+!(8303+&!
FRXUVHZLWKDGRJWKDW\RX¶YHWUDLQHGIURPWKHVWDUWDQGUHDFKWKHILQLVKOLQHNQRZLQJ\RX¶YHMXVWQDLOHGLW!
!
8"L'%9:5'#&;&#+'91&'/<&1&'F $17:E'."%D&/7/7":X'
\1*+!70(#1%*!17!(8303+&!(%$!9%1=$2!32+1!+,%$$!0$#$0*!±!21#36$4!32+$%-$'3(+$!(2'!-(*+$%*!X+,$!2(-$*!'377$%4!'$C
?$2'328!12!+,$!1%8(23B(+312Y.!Q18*!(%$!*$?(%(+$'!9(*$'!12!+,$3%!,$38,+!(+!+,$!)3+,$%*4!*1!'18*!(%$!61-?$+328!
(8(32*+!1+, $%!'18*!17!(??%1A3-(+$0&!+,$!*(-$!*3B$.!Q$?$2'328!12!+,$!1%8(23B(+3124!+,$%$!-(&!(0*1!9$!60(**$*!
(#(30(90$!71%!0 $**C(+,0$+36!'18 *!1%!71%!#$+$%(2 C0$#$0!'18*.!
!
O<9/'7+'9'/5D7.9#'&^D&17&:.&'9/'9'."%D&/7/7":'L<&:'+"%&":&'7+'+/91/7:E'"$/X'
<RX¶OOEHRYHUZKHOPHG$W\SLFDOORFDOVKRZLQWKLVDUHDZLOOKDYHDQ\ZKHUHIURPWRPRUHWKDQGRJV
DORQJZLWKWKHLUFUDWHVWKHLUSHRSOHVSHFWDWRUVDQGWKHFOXEWKDW¶VUXQQLQJWKHVKRZ,I\RXDUHWKLQNLQJDERXW
*,1)3284!*$%31<*0&!612*3'$%!81328!+1!*$#$%(0!*,1)*!9$ 71%$,(2'!+1!8$+!(!811'!<2'$%*+(2'328!17!),(+!3*!81328!
12.!"#$2!9$++$%4!# 10<2+$$%!+1!,$0?!±!\RX¶OOOHDUQDORWDQGWKHFOXEUXQQLQJWKHVKRZZLOODSSUHFLDWHLW!
!
8"L'.9:'9:'"L:&1'<&#D'9'F"E'F$17:E'/197:7:EX'
>&!?%1#3'328!60$(%!32?<+!+1!+,$!'18!+,%1<8,!+%$( +*4!+1&*!(2'!?0(&4!(2'!?%(3*$.!I,$2!+%(32328!(!'184!&1<!?%1#3'$!
+,$!120&!3271%-(+312!+,$!'18!,(*!(91<+!),$+,$%!,$!3*!'1328!),(+!&1<!)(2+.!!!
!
O<9/'91&'."%%":'%7+/9Q&+'/<9/'"L:&1+'%9Q&X'
([SHFWLQJDGRJWRNQRZKRZWRGRVRPHWKLQJKHKDVQ¶WEHHQWDXJKWDQGSXQLVKLQJDGRJIRUPDNLQJPLVWDNHV
WKDWDULVHIURPDQHUURULQKDQGOLQJRUIURPODFNRINQRZOHGJHRQWKHGRJ¶VSDUW!
!
O<9/'E&:&19#'/7D+'L"$#F'5"$'1&."%%&:F'/"'9'0&E7::&1X!
)LQGDQH[SHULHQFHGLQVWUXFWRU$GRJ¶VHDUO\WUDLQLQJLVLQVRPHVHQVHWKHPRVWLPSRUWDQW3URYLGLQJ\RXUGRJ
(!*103'!71<2'(+312!17!=21)0$'8$!(2'!*=300*!3*!+,$!=$&!+1!$A6$00328!(*!&1<!?%18%$**.!E+!3*!(0*1!3-?1%+(2+!+1!<2'$%C
*+(2'!,1)!'18*!0$(%2!±!'1328!*1!+$(6,$*!&1<!,1)!+1!+%(3 2!(!'18.!!!
!
8"L'.9:'+"%&":&'#&91:'%"1&'90"$/'9E7#7/5'/197:7:E'9:F'L<&1&'.9:'/<&5'E"'/"'E&/'/197:7: EX'''
*RRGVWDUWLQJSRLQWVIRUJHQHUDOWUDLQLQJDUHWKHERRNVE\,DQ'XQEDU-HDQ'RQDOGVRQDQG.DUHQ3U\RU:H¶G
(0*1!%$61--$2'!+,$!(8303+&!+%(32328!911=*!9&!M32'(!\$6=0$29<%84!@<*(2!L(%%$++4!"0363(!J(0,1<2!(2'!@+(6&!!
Z$(%'1+CL1<'&.!/!*<9*6%3?+312!+1!J0$(2!K<2!-(8(B32$!3*!%$61-- $2'$'!±!+,3*!3*!+,$!?%$-3$%!(8303+&!?<9036(+312.!
7KHLUZHEVLWHKDVDQH[FHOOHQWERRNVHFWLRQ:H¶GDOVRUHFRPPHQGORRNLQJDWWKH$.&DQG8QLWHG6WDWHV'RJ
/8303+&!/**163(+312!)$9*3+$*.!5,$%$!(%$!2< -$%1<*!7(6303+3$*!32!+,$!+%3C*+(+$!(%$(!+,(+!177$%!(8303+&!+%(32328!(+!(00!
0$#$0*.!5,$!9$*+!)(&!+1!732 '!12$!3*!+1!81!+1!(!016(0!(8303+&!+%3(0!(2'!+(0=!+1!$A,393+1%*.!
'
O<9/'F"&+'7/'."+/'/"'D91/7.7D9/&'7 :'."%D&/7/ 7":+X'
"2+%&!7$$*!*+(%+!(+!(%1<2'!f^`!?$%!%<2.!Q$?$2'3 28!12!+,$!(8303+&!1%8(23B(+3124!&1<!-(&!,(#$!(2&),$%$!7%1-!
+)1!+1!*3A!1%!-1%$! %<2*!32!(!'(&.!XJ0<9*!+&?36(00&!'3*61<2+!%<2*!),$2!+,$&!177$%!-(2&!?$ %!'(&.Y!!
!
O<&1&'<9;&'5 "$'E":&'I"1'/197:7:EX'
I$!,(#$!+(=$2!60(**$*!91+,!(+!1%8(23B$'!+%(32328!6$2+$%*!(2'!32 !-1%$!?%3#(+$!*$++328*.!5,$*$!3260<'$!@-(6=!
'DE¶V2EHGLHQFHWUDLQLQJIRURXUILUVWWUDLQLQJFODVVHVDQGORFDOWUDLQHUVLQFOXGLQJ'DQD3LNH'DYH%HKUHQV
K19$%+(!I,3+$*3'$*4!K1932!J1-?Cj$00$*!(2'!M(<%(!T$(%2.!I$!,(#$!(0*1!812$!+1!2<-$%1<*!(8303+&!*$-32(%*!(2'!
+%(32328!6(-?*!1#$%!+,$!&$(%*.!5,$*$!17+$2!7$(+<%$!+%(32$%*!),1!(%$!2(+312(00&!(2'!32+$%2(+312(00&!%$61823B $'!
(8303+&!$A?$%+*.!
>M*?*CY)'I1"%'D9E&'W''
'
'
45'N9#&']"<1'
3XSSLHVDUHFXWHDQG\RX¶OOJHWDORWRIORYHDQGOLYHOLQHVVIURPWKHP
><+!,(#$!&1<!$#$%!612*3'$%$'!('1?+328!(2!10'$%!'18H!
I,(+!3*!(2!10'$%!'18!±!W!1%!^_!&$(%*!10'H!J10 03$!K$*6<$!21%-(00&!'$732$*!
(2!10'$%!61003$!(*!-1%$!+,(2!W!&$(%*!10'4!)3+,!(!%$-(32328!037$!*?(2!17!
71<%!+1!$38,+!&$(%*.!5,$%$71%$4!+,$!('1?+312!7$$!(+!JKLE!3*!01)$%!71%!'18*!
W!(2'!10'$%.!5,$%$!(%$!?0$2+&!17!10'$%!'18*!32!(23-(0!*,$0+$%*4!9<+!61003$*!
32!+,$!\3')$*+!<*<(00&!8$+!%$7$%%$'!+1!JKLE.!!
:(#328!(!?$+!3 *!(!938!%$*?12*39303+&.!@1!9$71%$!&1<!('1?+ 4!-(=$!*<%$!&1<!
(%$!%$('&!71%!(!*$%3 1<*!61--3+-$2+.!
5,$%$!(%$!-(2&!
('#(2 +(8$*
!+1!('1?+328!(2!10'$%!61003 $.!T1%!$A(-?0$4!+,$!
VL]HDQGGLVSRVLWLRQZRQ¶WEHDVXUSULVHXQOLNHUDLVLQJDSXSS\!
<RX¶OOSUREDEO\NQRZOLWWOHDERXWWKHGRJVSDVW<RXZRQWNQRZLIKHLV
,1<*$9%1=$2!1%!+%(32$'.!:1)$#$%4 !(!71*+$%328!?% 18%(-4!*<6,!(*!+,$!
JKLE!*&*+$-4!?%1#3'$*!(*!-<6,!3271%-(+312!(*!?1**390$!(91<+!+,$!'18!+1!
(2!('1?+3#$!,1-$.!K$-$-9$%4!,$!,(*!,('!+1!('g<*+!+1!'377$%$2+!*3+<(C
+312*4!*1!?(+3$26$!3*!3-?$%(+3#$!)3+,!&1<%!2$)!61003$!(*!&1<!0$+!,3 -!=21)!
(2'!<2'$%*+(2'!& 1<%!?(++$%2!17!037$.!!
/'1?+328!10'$%!'18*!6(2!9$!#$%&!%$)(%'328!*326$!+,$&!(%$!6(0-$%!+,(2!
SXSVDQGGRQWUHTXLUHDVPXFKDWWHQWLRQ+H¶VSUREDEO\KDGWUDLQLQJ
>&!+,$!)(&4!&1<!6(2!+$(6,!10'!'18*!2 $)!+%36=*!(2'!+,$&!6(2!+$(6,!&1<!
*1-$!2$)!+%36=*!+11.!@<%$4!(2!10'$ %!'18!-(&!,(#$!*1-$!O<3%=*.!><+!
ZLWKSDWLHQFH\RXFDQKHOSKLPIHHODQGDFWEHWWHU+H¶OOTXLFNO\DGDSW
+1!&1<%!03 7$*+&0$!+1!9$61-$!(2!3-?1%+(2+!?(%+!17!+,$!7(-30&.!E7!&1<!(%$!(!
73%*+C+3-$!'18!1)2$%,!(2!10 '$%!'18!6(2!,$0?!&1<!8$+!<*$'!+1!('<0+!'188&!
)(&*.!F1<%!7011%*4!*,1$*!(2'!7<%23+<%$!)300!+,(2=!&1<!71%!('1?+328!(!*$2C
31%!?116,,")3+,!,3*!+$$+,3 28!&$(%*!9$,32'!,3 -.!
\(2&"'12;+!%$(03B$!+,(+!10'!'18*!(0*1!+$(6,!&1<2 8!'18*!(2'!#36$!#$%*(.!
/*!(!%<0$4!'18*!'12;+!03=$!+1!9$!(012$.!@ 1!37!&1<!,(#$!+)1!'18*4!+,$&!6(2!
?(0!(%1<2'!)3+,!$(6,!1+,$%.!F1<%!*$231%!'18!6(2!,$0?!+%(32!(!?<??&!+,(+!
&1<!-(&!732'!'37736<0+.!/!?<??&!011=*!<?!+1!(2!10'$%!'18!(2'!)(+6,$*!
,3-!601*$0&.!>$6(<*$!+,$!?<??&!-3-36*!+,$!10'$%!'184!,$!3*!(6+<(00&!
0$(%2328!811'!-(22$%*!7%1-!,3-.!5,$!10'$%!'18*!,(#$!*1)2 !+,$3%!1(+*4!
*1!+,$&!+$2'!+1!9$!811'!61-?(2312*!(2'!+$(6,$%*!71%!91+, !6,3 0'%$2!(2'!
?<??3$*.!
J%(+328!-(&!9$!2$6$**(%&!(2'!6,(00$28328!(+!73 %*+!)3+,!10'$%!'18*4!),1!
6(2!9$!*$+!32!+,$3%!)(&*!±!03=$!,<-(2*.!!I,(+$#$%!+,$!%$(*12*!+1!6 %(+$C
+%(32!&1<%!'184!&1<!-<*+!$A$%63*$!?(+3$26$!(2'!61-?(**312!+,%1<8,1<+!
+,$!?%16$**.!/23-(0!9$,(#31%3*+*!('#3*$!+1!0$(%2!&1<%!'18;*!91'&!0(2C
8<(8$.!K$3271%6$!811'!9$,(#31%!)3+ ,!?%(3*$!73%*+!(2'!+,$2!)3+,!(!, $(0+,&!
+%$(+.!/*!&1<!'$#$01?!(!811'!%$0(+312*,3?!)3+,!&1<%!*$231%!'184!,$!)30 0!
*112!9$!$(8$%!+1!?0$(*$4!71%8328!+,(+!32*+(2+!01#$!6122$6+312!+,(+!)3 00!
0(*+!(!037$+3-$.!
/!7%3$2'!17!-32$!732'*!+,(+!(2!10'$%!'18!,(*!(!O<(03+&!+,(+!6(2!9$!6(00$'!
D*1<0.D!>$6(<*$!17!,3*!&$(%*!17!%$0(+312*,3?*!)3+,!,<-(2*4!+,$!10'$%!'18!
,(*!(!'$$?!<2'$%*+(2'328!17!?$1?0$4!6%$(+328!(!, 38,!0$#$0!17!32 +<3+3#$!
61-?(2312*,3?.!Z$1?0$!)3+,!*$231%!'18*!17+$2!*, (%$!9$(<+37<0!*+1%3$*!
(91<+!+,$3%!$A?$%3$26$*.!5,$&!+$0 0!,1)!'$#1+$'!(2 '!8%(+$7<0!+,$!'18*!(%$!
(2'!,1)!+,$&!,(#$!9$2$73+$'!*,(%328!+,$3%!037$!)3+,!+,$!'18.!!
_'
\('30&2!Q3!@(0#1!*$2+!<*!(2!$-(304!
VLJQLQJLW³3URXGO\2ZQHGE\
.LQJ´
(2'!+,(+!*(&*!3+!(00G!!!
\('30&2!)(*!81328!+,%1<8,!(!%$(00&!
+1<8,!+3 -$.!@,$!01*+!,$%!-1+,$%4!
(2'!(!-12+,!0(+$%4!,$%!^VC&$(%C10'!
90(6=!0 (945(93+,(4!?(**$'!()(&.!!!!
@,$!)(*!8%3$#3 28!,$%!01**$*!+,$!
'(&!*,$!(2'!,$%!'(<8 ,+$%!?<00 $'!
32+1!Z$+61!+1!9<&!71 1'!71%!,$%!%$C
-(32328!'18.!/0+,1<8,!+,$!?0(6$!
)(*!g(-C?(6=$'!9$6(<*$!17!(2!
('1?+312!$#$2+4!*,$!%$6(00*!8$++328 !
(!?(%=328!*?1+!%38,+!32!7%12+.!!
³,GLGQRWQHHGWRZDONYHU\IDUWR
,(#$!+,$!90$**328!17!(!6,(26$!$2C
FRXQWHU´VD\V0DGLO\QZKRZDONV
ZLWKDFUXWFKGXHWRDEDGNQHH³,
)(*!*+%100328!1<+*3'$4!-(=328!-&!
)(&!+,%1<8,!(!-(B$! 17!'18*!(2'!
?$1?0$!+1)(%'!+,$!*+1%$!+1!'1!-&!
*,1??328 !),$2!E!7$0+!+,3*!)$+!21*$!
2<BB0328!-&!,(2'.!E!011=$'!'1)2!
(2'!*()!+,3*!938!61003$!2(-$'!P328!
8(B328!(+!-$.!E+!)(*!-<+<(0!01#$!
3--$'3(+$0&.!5,3*!938!'18!)1<0 '!
21+!0$(#$!-$!(012$ .!:$!'$63'$'!E!
)(*!3+G!E!'3'!21+!?36=!,3-k!,$!
SLFNHGPH´!
³,WROGP\GDXJKWHUµ7KLVDGRSWLRQ
ZDVPHDQWWREH«WKDWHDV\SDUN
328!*?1+!(2'!+,(+!)$+!21*$!),36,!
71<2'!-&!,(2'!+$00*!-$!E!,(#$!
IRXQGWKHSHUIHFWPDWFK¶6R,
7300$'!1<+!+,$!('1?+312!?(?$%)1%=!
RQWKHVSRW´VKHVD\V!
0DGLO\Q¶VUHGKHHOHUZKRZDVWKH
(0?,(4
!(66$?+$'!P328!(*!,$%!0$('$%.!
6KHKDVEHFRPH³KLVTXHHQ´
\('30&2!$A?0(32*!)3+,!(!0 (<8,.!!
:$%!8%(2'6,30'%$2!01#$!P3284!(*!'1!
(00!+,$!2$38,91%,11'!=3'*.!:$!)$0C
61-$*!+,$-!12!,3*!)(0=*!(2'!
8%$$+*!+,$-!)3+,!(!)(88328!+(30.!!!
³+LVMRELVWRJXDUGWKHIHQFHOLQH
(2'!,$!-(=$*!+,$! %1<2'*!$#$%&!
+3-$!,$!81$*!1<+.!:$!3*!?%1+$6+328!
KLVNLQJGRPKLVIDPLO\´VKHVD\V!
4&:&I7/+'"I'>F"D/7:E'9:'-#F&1'N"E'
8&9;&:'@&:/'
@&&'G*\M)'D9E&'`'
!
`'
!
.LG·V&RUQHU
³6RPHSHRSOHZRXOGWKLQNWKLV
*1<2'*!(!03 ++0$!6%(B&4!9<+!E!=21)!
P328!)(*!*$2+!+1!-$.!:$!3*!*1!
*?$63(0.!E!)(*!8 1328!+,%1<8,!*<6,!
(!'37736<0+!+3-$!32!-&!037$!(2'!7$$0C
328!*<6,!8%3$7!),$2!E!7$0+!+,(+!)$+!
QRVH´VKHVD\V³,NQRZP\
90(6=!0 (94!5(93+,(4!'3'!21+!)(2+!
+1!0$(#$!-$4!9<+!*,$!)(*!10'4!*36=!
(2'!+3%$'.!E!+,32=!*,$!'$63'$'4!
*326$!*,$!61<0'!21+!*+(&4!*,$!
)1<0'!g< *+!73A!-$!<?.!\$$+328!
.LQJZDVQRDFFLGHQW´!
5%<0&4!P328!3*!(!837+!(2'!+,3*!3*!(!
-(+6,!-('$!7%1-!,$(#$2G!!!!!!!
G*\M)'I1"%'D9E&'_'
!
J"##7&'D<"/"'05'J9##&']R)'(W'
[1,2!J&-$%-(24!Z%$*3'$2+! !
]36=3!I30'$%4!]36$!Z%$*3'$2+!
532(!P3*$0=(4!5%$(*<%$%!
J(%1032$!M$)3*4!@$6%$+(%&!
K19$%+!h0*124!I$9-(*+$%SE5!
P3-!j(2'*+%(4!J,(3%?$%*12!
\36,$00$!:3%*6,4!"#$2+!J11%'32(+1%
!
\36,$00$!K18$%*4!/'1?+312!J11%'32(+1%!
@<*3$!\126$=4!T1*+$%!:1-$!J11%'32(+1%!!
2+//'-*3-(4"-*+0*5%-&,-%*6//'#+'(:*6#47:*'(*&*#+#<%+0',*4+%<+%&,'+#*
-(,&1/'(.-$*'#*WXXY7*8-*<%+='$-*(.-/,-%*&#$*4&%-*,+*<"%-1%-$*4+//'-(*
;.'4.*.&=-*1--#*&1&#$+#-$*+%*,"%#-$*'#*,+*(.-/,-%(7*K>&'/*
'#0+Z4+//'-%-(4"-7+%):*4&//*FI[JG*\WYBW]JI*+%*='(',*,.-*;-1(',-*
;;;74+//'-%-(4" -7+%)7*
4"91F']&%0&1+'
*